The Jesus Phone

I happened to be near the Apple Store yesterday. (Buying a geek book for work down the street from it.) I wandered in. The hype crowd had cooled down but it was still hoppin' for a cool summer evening. A Monday no less.

Now I know Buckethead is drooling over the phone, but I've been interested in it because I am looking for a laptop alternative. I hate blogging inside my house on a nice day. I would love to go to a cafe and blog over WiFi and check out the jarheads on PT runs. What good is living near the Pentagon if you don't get gym queen eye candy? (Really, it's like living in the Castro in SF again, except the men are straight and not quite as ripped.) But I digress.

I really want a laptop and was seriously considering a MacBook, priced the damned thing and everything. Looked at the refurbs, offered to buy one off a girlfriend who hated hers. (She and I are of the same ilk, no lifting your hands off the keyboard to use the mouse. It wastes time.) But I thought maybe I should wait a see what this iPhone thingamabob is all about. You see, I have a 4GB Nano I won in a blog contest and I really don't use it. I have an indash 6-CD changer and usually that's enough music to last me months without a change. I even mislaid the thing for a few months because I just don't need audio white noise in my life. I abandoned my Palm V after I didn't have a desktop anymore to sync it to pull down articles from AvantGo and read them on the train and because I was a car commuter and didn't have the time to read anymore.

So here I am at the store. I looked at an iPhone and started to use it as instinctively as I knew how because a really great GUI doesn't need instructions. It should be intuitive and obvious. Right?

Well, I had heard a little about how the button gets you always back to the start page with your icons. I admit, it's a beautifully clear screen with great width, but it's about the size of my old Palm V and still feeling a bit large in the hand. (I use a KRZR right now, not crazy about it, but it's narrow, which I like.)

After about 30 seconds, I wanted to hurl the damned thing across the room. Luckily for Apple and its patrons, it was bolted down.

Excuse me, but this gadget was designed by men for men. Being the girly girl that I am, I keep my fingernails long. I like to scratch the itch. There's nothing more satisfying than bearing down and taking a layer of dermis off when you've got a terrible itch. Unfortunately, that precludes using this device. Period. End of story. I don't even need to proceed any further. If you are not a nail biter, you can never use this phone.

All the men around me thought it was the bomb. I glanced at their fingers. They were all effing nail biters. Shit. Even I AM a nail biter when I am bored at work, but I don't bite down to the quick. That's disgusting and makes your fingers bleed, an even worse biohazard. But of course their fat sausage fingers are greasy and skating right across the glass surface. The idea of that makes me nauseated and reach for the Windex.

All around me I heard was that it was amazing. Honestly, I don't think it's that great. It's still not going to replace a laptop and wireless connection for a person like me. Either I want a phone or I want a highly connective mobile device, but apparently what I really want is a sub-notebook about 4-6" across with a wireless card, and a full-size 110-key folding keyboard accessory. The Jesus phone doesn't cut the mustard at all. (I am seriously thinking of patenting that idea so if any of you are electrical engineers with experience in injection molded plastics, please contact me.)

I don't have chunky fingers and I was still mistyping out the wazoo. I literally had to hunt and peck with my ring finger (shortest fingernail) to type. The interface could not keep up with my speed. Also, for the auto guessing of words, I couldn't easily figure out at first which button would complete the fill because I could not accurately ascertain which one I was hitting. (Why does the return key actually do a carriage return after it autofills? That's crap. Auto fill with no line break.) I did try covering my finger with my shirt tail and typing, which was surprisingly effective, even through a couple layers of fabric. I hear that with gloves on, it's impossible to use, which sort of precludes outdoor winter use, say in front of a bar grabbing a smoke trying to get your friends to meet you inside in 15 minutes as they walk from the metro. (Who says the smoking ban in SF, NYC and DC sucks? At least you get clear signal outside!)

The other thing that really struck me as poorly done is that the screen automatically rotates the output for web browsing. Ok, that's pretty neat and a good idea. But when you use Safari and the top tilts 90 degrees to the right, that's great. I'm a righty and that instinctive for me. But when I was looking at the embedded YouTube application, IT TILTED THE OTHER WAY. Um, not cool to have to rotate it 180 degrees from the web browser just to watch video. That's insane. The Apple dweebie in the store insisted that I had done something wrong, however, a device should never automatically switch from one orientation to the other like that spontaneously. I should be able to set it to a righty setting and lefties should get their own setting. That's a pretty reasonable GUI expectation.

To be fair, my blog looked GREAT onscreen! So did my blogpal, David's blog (see the iPhone inputted comment I left there and the crappy typos). And PFBlogs.org. Three sites I would definitely visit if I had a mobile device. I have a PSP and I have tried to use WiFi to browse the web with it, but frankly it sucks. The iPhone is VAST improvement over that. The incoming sound over iPod headphones was ok. I didn't get a chance to hear back from anyone about how the phone messages sounded that I left for them. (Buckethead?)

OH. Word to the hygiene wise, if you wish to go to see this device, TAKE YOUR OWN HEADPHONES. It was vile to watch the unwashed masses use the the same headphones over and over. I happened to have my iPod in my purse and used my own self-defiled headphones, thank-you-very-fucking-cleanliness-much. I only wish I had Purell because I was touching that screen all over and was getting grossed out. I didn't want to put it up to my face to use lest my skin I break out from necrotizing faciitis. Really, you cannot be too careful around these Mac fans. While their brand image may be clean, oy vey, their clientele is not. And this is the NoVA, BMW-driving yuppie crowd. It was teh ick. And for those not in the know, I am not a clean freak, but basic public health demands some more caution. Thank god it came out in the summertime, because during flu season, it would be quite the vector for spreading germs. (Don't even tell me that these are special headphones with the mic in the cord, I don't care. It's gross. Do want me to breathe all over your food the next time we dine together?)

Ok, that's enough of my ranting. You get the point. I'm not throwing away money on this thing. I pity Buckethead who will probably shed tears of joy when he first gets it and the curse AT&T 6 months later for the poor service. (News tip, VERY VERY LATE on Friday afternoon, 6pm ish EDT, AT&T announced the purchase of Dobson Telecom, which will give them better coverage in flyover country, so in a year, complaints about spotty service around the US might actually be moot. I presume I will still not be able to get a signal from inside the anechoic chamber better known as my parents' home. I swear, the NSA doesn't even block radio signal that well. Only Verizon gets through there. Sprint, Nextel AT&T nothing. You have to walk down the driveway to the sidewalk to get signal.)

[wik] I really, really, really wanted to like this phone. I did. I really want to be one of the cool kids and I was hoping it would be suitable for what I want, but alas, it's not. I *heart* Steve Jobs and I'd give my left pinkie to go work at Pixar, even if that would slow down my typing, I'd do it. There's something hot about the turtleneck and the rimless glasses, but I bet he's another psycho behind the wheel of a black BMW, because he definitely is a megalomaniac.

Posted by Mapgirl Mapgirl on   |   § 10

§ 10 Comments

1

Mark,

I have used a BB for work. It was an older one but I had small problem with the keys, but it wasn't terrible. It also had a slight issue keeping up.

I have used a friend's Treo Smartphone as well. Too narrow, but tolerable. Heck, it's the reason I was thinking that the iPhone was feasible.

Whether I turned it sideways or not really didn't matter. Apparently I don't have a glob of flesh on my thumbs in the right spot and would get contact from the side of my thumbtips, not the center.

Sideways was better though in general, just the annoying thing about tipping one way or the other.

I concur that all phones suck. The KRZR is one of the worst phones I've ever owned. I have all these speed dial numbers, but if you try to speed dial a number assigned to #5, it actually calls '5' and tells you it's an invalid number. STOOPID. For some reason, the same software on an older phone did not have this problem, but I admit, I haven't upgraded the software in the 4 months I've owned it.

2

I'm writing this comment on an iphone in Bethesda and I find the keyboard pretty easy to use.

Doing two to finger typing isnt too bad - the auto complete is pretty good

I love it

It is teh precious.

3

Heh,

Well, I won't buy one because A:) It csosts a minimum of 500 clams, plus another 135 for the activation and first month's service. There's also the peripherals to buy, so prolly 750 with taxes and all that. You also have to sell your soul to the Death Star.

I bought a trackphone for 15 bucks. Added 400 minutes for less than 50 bucks. It does txts, voicemail and I can now call people when away from my house.

I had thought about a Mac power book as well. Might do it, but it's so bloody expensive. Prolly get an Acer, 'cause I sure the christ won't buy a Dell. Crappy tech and service. Horrible staffers.

This iphone looked way kewl to me at first glance. the more I looked at it, and added up the costs, the more I said noway.

Respects,

4

Mapgirl, what's your experience like with a blackberry or blackjack or similar devices? Do your nails preclude those as well? Just curious.

The lack of tactile feedback on the iPhone is definitely one of my worries. A buddy at work said he played with one and had a lot of trouble using the keyboard when he held the phone in the upright position. When he turned it sideways, it was a lot better.

The other annoying thing is the lack of 3G support. I was watching over shoulder as someone attempted to load my work's website, and it took forever. On a blackjack with 3G, it comes up right away.

Personally, I think I'm going to wait for the second generation iPhone before making the leap... but you know, all the other phones out right now suck. I mean, they REALLY suck. The iPhone, warts and all, is still 10 times better than some of the crap out there right now...

5

Maps:

Why do you hate our iPhones, to say nothing of our fat fingers?

6

Back at the desk, where I can type faster - I have to say that I was really impressed. I expected to be, granted, but that phone is one highly enslickened piece of hardware.

I was getting reasonably fast with two-fingered typing even after a few minutes. I think in a small amount of time, I'd be fast. For me at least, the touchscreen "issue" is a non starter. The touchscreen is really responsive - the screen transitions are just as fast as they are on the demo, and really artfully done. Lots of attention to detail. Everything is obvious - excellent UI design. It does not feel like a first generation release.

And, amazingly, perfidy looked better on the iPhone screen than it does on my pc.

7

"And, amazingly, perfidy looked better on the iPhone screen than it does on my pc."

No surprise there - I've recently been using Safari rather than IE, and since the bugs are largely ignorable, I find it just to be a better browsing experience, for reasons I can't fully describe.

Those Apple bastards surely do know their UI design.

8

Fellers,

Don't get me wrong here. I think the Iphone is pretty neat. If I were in a financial position to buy one, I might well do it. However, at the moment, I am in more need of a laptop, and for what the Iphone would cost me I can still get a pretty good one with some serious shopping. Heck, my oldest just bought herself a laptop at half-dot-com for about 600 bucks, and it's a darned nice one at that.

Ah well..

Respects,

9

Guys, and I do mean, guys, I'm not cutting my fingernails off just to use a piece of technology.

There is a bad practice out there of modifying the user's practices to fit the software. Life should not be like that. Good GUI design means that everyone with fingers should be able to use the product, with or without fingernails.

Sorry, but that's life. In our still latently gender biased world, a woman is subtley smiled upon for keeping her nails a slightly past her fingertips and polished, even if it's only with clear. That means no-go on the iPhone.

[ You're too late, comments are closed ]